What Officially Went Wrong

A recent post from InsureBlog summarized a 92 page report from The HHS Office of Inspector General on the failure of the Obamacare exchange.  Here are the highlights provided on their blog, which explain the main causes of the Obamacare challenges:

The development of HealthCare.gov faced a high risk of failure, given the technical complexity required, the fixed deadline, and a high degree of uncertainty about mission, scope, and funding. Still, we found that HHS and CMS made many missteps throughout development and implementation that led to the poor launch. Most critical was the absence of clear leadership, which caused delays in decisionmaking, lack of clarity in project tasks, and the inability of CMS to recognize the magnitude of problems as the project deteriorated. Additional HHS and CMS missteps included devoting too much time to developing policy, which left too little time for developing the website; making poor technical decisions; and failing to properly manage its key website development contract. CMS’s organizational structure and culture also hampered progress, including poor coordination between policy and technical work, resistance to communicating and heeding warnings of “bad news,” and reluctance to alter plans in the face of problems. CMS continued on a failing path to developing HealthCare.gov despite signs of trouble, making rushed corrections shortly before the launch that proved insufficient. These structural, cultural, and tactical deficiencies were particularly problematic for HealthCare.gov given the significant challenges of implementing a new program involving multiple stakeholders and a large technology build.

See a related Washington Post article here:

Some Insurance Companies are Losing Money on Obamacare Exchanges

A recent article in the Wall Street Journal details the financial sustainability for insurance carriers as it relates to the Affordable Care Act Exchanges (Marketplaces).  Journalist Anna Wilde Mathews explains why the insurance companies are under pressure to improve their margins on all of their ACA health plan offerings.  For example, a recent analysis of Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans, found that they paid out more for health care in the first three quarters of 2015, than they received in premiums on their Individual plans.

Though the health law has added customers to many insurers' rolls, much of that growth has been unprofitable, reflecting medical costs that have often run ahead of what insurers projected when they set premiums, among other factors.

Also recently in the headlines, CNN Money reported that UnitedHealth expects to lose nearly $1 billion on plans they offer through the Obamacare exchanges.

UnitedHealth, which sat out the first year of Obamacare in 2014, said it is not looking to grow its exchange business. Instead, it has increased prices, eliminated marketing and commissions and withdrawn its top-tier products. In an effort to stem the losses, it is also working more closely with providers and enrollees to manage their illnesses and care.
UnitedHealth warned in November that it might pull out of the Obamacare exchanges altogether in 2017, citing higher-than-expected claims. In particular, it blamed the large number of members signing up outside the open enrollment period who were using a lot of medical services.
Some insurers argue that Americans are waiting until they get sick to sign up and then finding a way to qualify during the so-called special enrollment period, which is traditionally open to those who change jobs, get married or divorced or have a baby. The Obama administration has since said it would tighten the rules for joining Obamacare during this period.

Time will tell if these losses result in higher premiums, higher out-of-pocket costs, or insurance carriers pulling out of the market altogether.

Email Marketing 101 for the Insurance Professional

Times are changing, fast. In the last few years the insurance agent client relationship has changed in a big way. With the development of incredible communication tools it is easier than ever to keep in touch with all of your clients on a personal basis. With tools like a website, email, and social media you can keep your clients in the know while finding new potential clients. Today we will look at email marketing in depth and see how it can be used to keep your old customers and foster new clients.

Email marketing has been around for over two decades, but the tools has gotten considerably better over the years. Now with tracking you can truly understand what your clients want to know more about and what they don’t care about anymore. 

Keeping Up with your Clients

The first thing you should make sure that you need to be doing is keeping in touch with your clients on regular basis. Having a weekly or monthly newsletter just to keep up and make sure they know all of the benefits available to them. By reaching out to your clients and keeping them up to date on benefits, new plans, or just a place for them to email you back and ask a question.

Keep your newsletters short but informative. Have around 5 pieces of content in each newsletter, and explain new things in a language that your clients will understand. By being transparent you will make a strong connection with your customers that will keep them loyal for years to come.

Fostering New Relationships

Keeping up with your current clients is only part of the equation for email marketing. The real potential in email marketing is reaching out to people that are not yet clients to show to them why they need to become your customers. By reaching out to these potential clients and informing them about the perks of signing up with you they will understand what makes you the superior choice to be their agent. 

In this newsletter make sure to include interesting and informative articles and videos on the plans you offer, on the benefits of your company and a simple and easy way that they can contact you for more information. 

Use the Data

After you have sent your emails you need to look into the data and see what interested your subscribers and what they don’t care about. By keeping a constant eye on the data you can easily tweak what you send to be more interesting to your readers. If you do it right people will be excited to get your emails and be interested in what you have to say.


By using email marketing to its fullest you can cultivate the relationships you already have and create new potential relationships so that you can grow your business in a way that was never possible before. 

If you are open and honest in your newsletters you will connect with your subscribers in ways that were only dreamed of years ago, which will lead to real gains in your bottom line.

Want to learn more about how to do email marketing? You can read more about email marketing here.

Azriel Ratz, CEO of Ratz Pack Media, is an expert in social media, email marketing, and online advertising. He has been working in the industry for several years. If you have any questions or comments about this article contact him directly at ARatz@RatzPackMedia.com.  

How To Use the BenefitCompare Tool - Webinar

Our goal at BenefitCompare is to create an effortless user experience for health insurance brokers when comparing plans for their clients.  We have a simple user-interface, extensive help resources, and unlimited customer service to help you in navigating the tool.

Special ACA Open Enrollment For Small Groups

Guaranteed Availability Provision of the ACA (Affordable Care Act)

If you have small employer groups who don’t meet participation requirements, but want to offer coverage, there is a solution. Between November 15th and December 15th, 2015, there is a special open enrollment window where employers that don’t meet minimum requirements will be able to offer coverage to their employees. Take advantage of this opportunity to compare health insurance plans and write small groups that don’t meet traditional contribution and participation.

Important enrollment reminders for your employer groups:

  • Effective date of coverage: January 1, 2016
  • Deadline for completed applications and all supporting documents: Dec 15, 2015
  • Employer Contribution on the New Group Application must be completed
  • Write “Guaranteed Availability” visibly on the top of the group application
  • Groups that enroll in this period will be subject to recertification at renewal

Be sure to consult your carrier's sales representative for important details and writing requirements related to this one-time special provision. If you submit a group under this special opportunity after December 15, 2015, carriers cannot accept it per ACA guidelines.

Help your agency to grow its client database

Insurance Broker Management Software

BenefitCompare is a new time saving health insurance broker software web application. It easily syncs across all devices including your desktop, tablet, or mobile. Not only can the software help brokers with client management, it is a powerful tool that offers quick and easy cost sharing (defined benefit and defined contribution allocations), broker proposals, and client decision support. BenefitCompare is a software solution for insurance brokers throughout California to help clients with their healthcare needs. While BenefitCompare is not a CRM application in the traditional sense, it does help brokers with client management and increasing insurance sales. There’s nothing to download. Sign up for a free trial and begin using the time-saving broker management/insurance quoting software app today!

Employer Costs and Estimating Best Plan Options for Clients

The Kaiser Family Foundation recently conducted an annual survey of employers providing "...a detailed look at trends in employer-sponsored health coverage including premiums, employee contributions, cost-sharing provisions, and employer opinions. The 2015 survey included almost 2,000 interviews with non-federal public and private firms."

The Wall Street Journal recently published an article based on these results.  Journalist Anna Wilde Matthews wrote that nationally, "...the average cost of employer health coverage passed $17,000 for a family plan this year, despite continued muted growth on a percentage basis..."

In California, CHCF conducted a similar study on employer coverage, costs, and benefits -- and published the results in March, which can be found here:

Using this data and other benchmarks, the BenefitCompare tool automatically makes plan recommendations based on an employee and/or family's anticipated medical claims.  BenefitCompare gives you estimated out-of-pocket costs for local specific claims based off your bronze, silver, gold, or platinum plan.

New Consumer Site Provides Quality Ratings & Costs!

A new site recently released by California state officials is really a breakthrough for consumers of health insurance.  They can now look up the average costs for the most common medical procedures based on location, as well as review the quality ratings of various providers.

The consumer site can be accessed here:

The BenefitCompare tool will include a convenient link to this site for both agents and their employer groups to easily access while narrowing down their plan options.  The hardest part about choosing a health plan is understanding the true cost of premiums, treatments, and cost-sharing.  With this consumer website linked for easy access, it will help employers and their employees have simplicity and clarity as it pertains to their true overall out-of-pocket costs.

Barbara Feder Ostrov of Kaiser Health News covered the details of this new consumer site, along with links to other useful sites for quality reviews of hospitals (affiliated with Medicare), and CalQualityCare.org, "which provides information on the state’s hospitals, doctor groups, nursing homes, assisted living facilities, home health and hospice services, adult day care, and services for the developmentally disabled."  You can access the full article by clicking on the KHN logo on the right.

BenefitCompare is dedicated to making agents' lives easier, so they can provide valuable evaluation tools that aren't available through straight proposals with a general agent.  With this added consumer site, your clients will have a full picture of the true costs of medical care.

See below for a related article on this new state website in the Los Angeles Times:

If you or your client(s) have used the new website, we encourage you to comment below and share your experience.

Covered CA Mailing Regarding 2016 Subsidy Eligibility

On August 14, 2015, Covered California sent letters to members who currently receive subsidies through the Affordable Care Act.  The letter advised them that they must give their consent for Covered California to verify their income and family size to determine their subsidy eligibility for their health plan in 2016.



  • Calling Covered CA at 1-800-300-1506 or by
  • Logging into their www.CoveredCA.com account and following the instructions in their letter

If members do not provide the necessary information to Covered CA by the 9/30/15 deadline, their subsidy will end on 12/31/15.

The Cadillac Tax

Recent ACA discussion has turned to the so-called "Cadillac Tax" (scheduled to take effect in 2018), which is a 40% non-deductible excise tax on employer-sponsored health coverage that provides high-cost benefits.  It's expected to affect over 25% of employers as the regulation is currently written.  Cigna provides the following PDF on their website with more details on how it would work, including IRS requirements:

The Washington Post's Carolyn Johnson wrote in the Wonkbook today:

The next fight over the Affordable Care Act may center on one of its most powerful provisions to contain health care costs — the "Cadillac tax" on the most generous health insurance plans.
A new analysis released this week by the Kaiser Family Foundation estimated that just over a quarter of employers that offer health plans would pay the 40 percent tax in 2018 on at least one plan if they don't make changes. The National Business Group on Health, a nonprofit association of large employers, found that half of its members reported that at least one of their health plans would trigger the tax in 2018. Both groups predicted that the proportion of employers affected would go up significantly over time.
That means many employers are scrambling to find ways to avoid the tax. Ultimately, that will probably mean a combination of paring benefits and shifting cost to employees through high deductible plans, capping or eliminating flexible savings accounts, and offering less generous plans that, for example, limit access to a narrower networks of doctors and hospitals.

"The 'Cadillac tax' will have a very powerful effect on health care costs, and that certainly a good thing. But the way the tax helps to keep health costs down is primarily by shifting it to workers," said Larry Levitt, a senior vice president at the Kaiser Family Foundation who did the analysis. "While it certainly sounds good to control heath care costs, the way it is likely to happen won’t feel very good to consumers."

The opposition to the tax comes from a motley collection of unlikely allies, beyond the usual cast of anti-tax Republicans. In late July, The Alliance to Fight the 40 launched a concerted campaign against the tax, backed by a coalition that puts the insurer Cigna, the labor group Unite Here, the utility Eversource Energy, and school districts on the same side.  The Hill reported that House Republicans will likely put repealing the tax on the fall agenda. Even Hillary Rodham Clinton is concerned.

The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation has excellent resources and research on the "Cadillac Tax" and many other topics related to health care reform:

Also related to the Cadillac Tax, BenefitsPro.com published an article on how the regulation might affect FSA's (flexible spending accounts):

As always, we welcome your thoughts and comments below.

3 Ways To Input Census Data

The census starts your client file on BenefitCompare and is required to use our budget and reporting tools. When deciding to add a census, you have three different ways to get census data into the system quickly & easily.

Import File

If your existing census data is saved as a file on you computer, you can get your file’s data into the Benefit Compare system by clicking “Import File.” it will accept Excel spreadsheet (xls, or xlsx) files.  

Add Clipboard

If you have existing census data as text, you can copy the text to your computer’s clipboard and click on the “Clipboard” option where you’ll be able to cut-and-paste a tab-defined or csv file. Easy formatting instructions are on the following page.

Typing In A Census

If you only have a few people in your census, the easiest way might be to manually input your data. Click on the “Type Census” button and follow the direction on the following page.

Client Management Page

On the “Client Management Page” you can create new client files and access your existing client files in your Benefit Compare account.

First, the system automatically generates a new generic client company name along with a numeric value. To customize the new file name, you can click on the company name text, and personalize the data for your group. Once you are satisfied with your changes, click OK.

To create a new client, click on “add a new client” to begin importing census information.

To view your existing clients in the database, click “View All” to view your entire client file list.

To locate a specific case file in the database, you can search by name and your case file will be displayed below.

To customize or view the selected group’s contact information, click on the gear icon.

To delete a company, click on view all and select the company name.  This will bring you to company the overview page where you can click remove.

To log off your account at any time, you can click on the X.

Supreme Court Decision on Same-Sex Marriage

Aetna recently notified brokers that their enrollment deadline has been extended for applicable members/spouses affected by the same-sex marriage ruling.  Check each carrier site for how they are applying the ruling to their own members, but they will likely have similar changes to the Aetna updates outlined below.

To summarize the ruling, on June 26, 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court decided that all states must license a marriage between two people of the same sex and honor marriages licensed in another state.  As a result of this ruling, Aetna said that "fully insured health plans offered by Aetna in all states now cover same sex spouses the same way they cover spouses of the opposite sex. "

What this means for Aetna members on insured plans:

  • Members who were legally married on or after June 26, 2015 will have 31 days from the date of marriage to enroll their same-sex spouses.
  • Members who were legally married prior to June 26, 2015 but were not allowed to enroll their same-sex spouses in their fully insured plan now have until August 28, 2015 to enroll their spouses.
  • There will be no special enrollment period for members who were married prior to June 26, 2015 who were allowed previously to enroll their same-sex spouse.
  • Members who miss an enrollment deadline, will need to wait for the next open enrollment period, or experience a qualifying event, before adding their spouse.

According to Aetna, what this means for your clients:

The changes outlined above only apply to insured plans.  Self-funded plans should consult with their legal counsel as they decide how to handle eligibility for same-sex spouses.
This ruling does not impact domestic partnership benefits.  If, however, a group wishes to make a change to domestic partnership benefits, and state law allows it, [Aetna] will make the change at renewal.
Groups may still have the option to choose whether they cover employee spouses, but if they cover some spouses, they must cover all.

Aetna encourages brokers to contact their Aetna Representative with any specific questions or for additional information.

Preparing Your Self-Insured Clients for 2016 Tax Reporting

California Broker magazine (www.CalBrokerMag.com) published an article in their August issue explaining the "ABC's of Preparing Your Self-Insured Clients" for the extensive reporting requirements under the Affordable Care Act (aka Obamacare).  It's better to prepare them now so your employer groups are offering the right coverage, filing the correct forms for each employee, and avoiding penalties in the future.  We've linked to the article below:

The article covers the mandates regarding affordability, employee tracking, which IRS forms need to be filed, deadlines that need to be observed, and helpful resources that are available.  

As a reminder, BenefitCompare also offers a complimentary membership to HR360 for our agent/broker members (more details below):

Employers, HSA's, and Education

One of the many benefits of using our tool, is that agents/brokers can define an HSA plan benefit option to compare, and then BenefitCompare will summarize the net costs to employers, often bringing better coverage with lower overall costs to both employer and employee.

A recent article in Employee Benefit Adviser pointed out that even though HSA's are a valuable plan offering, a better understanding is needed:

 "...employees remain confused about HSAs and more education could help them utilize the accounts to their fullest intent and realize more savings for employers. The good news for advisers is most consumers prefer one-to-one conversations to improve their knowledge, according to the findings of a survey of more than 300 health care industry professionals conducted by Acclaris."

See also our blog post / video learning resource on explaining HSA's:

As a plan benefit adviser, do you offer HSA's to your clients?  We welcome your thoughts in the comments section below.

Complimentary HR & Compliance Service for our Brokers

As a free benefit to our BenefitCompare users, we have partnered with HR360 to provide Human Resource help and Benefits Compliance resources.  At HR360, they offer:

  • an HR Library
  • HR Apps, Forms, & Tools
  • Health Care Reform Updates
  • HR Training
  • Guidance on How-to Hire, Manage, and Terminate Employees
  • HR Training Videos

Learn how the HR Library can help your employer group clients by watching a short video on their home page:

From supervising employees…and staying compliant with Health Care Reform…to complying with federal and state labor laws…HR360 provides assistance with attorney-reviewed HR tools, HR guidelines, HR forms and HR training videos.
If you haven't already received an email invite to log into the site, we'll be gradually contacting all of our agent users throughout the year.  If you'd like access to HR360 sooner, just give us a call or click on the "Contact Us" form of our website, we'll get your welcome email sent right away.

We're grateful for all our loyal agent and broker BenefitCompare users and happy to continue to offer outstanding customer service and compliance assistance in the post health reform world.


Zenefits offers online HR & payroll software, along with benefits and insurance management for small and medium employers.  Their website states it offers:

...free online HR Software that gives your team a single place to manage all your human resource needs - payroll, benefits, compliance and more.

In offering these services, they have taken over accounts previously managed by independent brokers and agencies in California (and across the U.S.), giving them a reputation for taking away business to some industry observers.

Employee Benefit Advisor magazine recently featured an article about the CEO and their company, defending its business model, and assuring its readers it is not "anti-broker":

BuzzFeed published another article from the consumer point of view, showing the good and bad that can come from losing that "personal touch":

With its explosive growth and ..."its stated goal of eliminating middlemen like insurance brokers, Zenefits has become a threat to its entrenched competition faster than most startups":

If you're an agent, have you had any clients switch to Zenefits?  Any employers/employees who use Zenefits, please share your comments/experience below.

Taxing Blue Shield of California

Back in August of 2014, Blue Shield of California lost its tax-exempt status after the Franchise Tax Board determined that it no longer qualified as a nonprofit based on its business practices.  The state's audit concluded that they "...stress profitability..." and "...are inconsistent with an organization organized as a nonprofit which desires tax-exempt status." 

Some articles from the Los Angeles Times that covered the story:

For its part, Blue Shield believes it is "a mission-driven organization that answers to members and not shareholders..." and continues to maintain that its mission is "For Care, Not Profit":

A reliable source at Blue Shield told us they do not believe their executives have any incentive to maximize profitability stating, "Since Blue Shield has a 2% net income cap, its rates reflect the cost of health care and not higher profits.  But despite its not-for-profit mission, Blue Shield faces the same market realities and rising costs as its competitors."

Blue Shield states on their website, some of the many ways it distinguishes itself from its competition:

We strive to uphold high standards of ethical business practices in our programs, products, and interactions with everyone we serve. In fact, we have been recognized as one of the World’s Most Ethical Companies in 2012 and 2013 by Ethisphere Institute.
We practice social responsibility as a company, protect the environment and volunteer in local communities. 
The Blue Shield of California Foundation is funded entirely by Blue Shield of California contributions, and has awarded more than $200M in grants since 2005 to community organizations to make healthcare effective, safe and accessible, particularly for underserved communities. The Foundation is also dedicated to ending domestic violence through a coordinated network of service, support, and education.

An article published by Southern California Public Radio, a member-supported public media network, discussed what this will mean for the carrier and the consumers: 

What do you think it means?  Was it a fair decision?  Comment below and share your thoughts!

Health Insurance Carrier Mergers

Recent billion-dollar mergers between carriers has been making news, including Aetna investing $37 billion to acquire Humana, a major player in the Medicare Advantage sector.  In light of these changes, we decided to post articles from various sources on the most recent merger between Anthem and Cigna.  We encourage agents in California to comment below with their opinions and feedback on how this will affect consumers, employers, agents, and shape the future of the industry.

UPDATE August 5, 2015 - Article in LifeHealthPRO addresses the carrier mergers and what it will mean for the health insurance industry:

Cigna Won't Pay Brokers for Individual Sales in 4th Quarter

Cigna recently sent an email to brokers and posted on their website (under "News You Can Use") that they plan to "pay 0% commission" to agents and brokers who sell their Individual and Family Plans in the 4th quarter of 2015.  This will affect all plans sold after 8/22/15 for effective dates 9/1/15 through 12/31/15.  Details of the update are as follows:

Please be advised that we are adjusting our Cigna Individual and Family Plan medical commission schedules effective September 1, 2015. Sales submitted on/after August 22nd for September 1st through December 31st effective dates will earn 0% commission. Commission schedules have been updated on the portal. This decision only impacts business submitted with effective dates of September 1st through December 31, 2015. Business for 2016 will be paid at posted commission rates that will be announced prior to the 2016 Open Enrollment Period.
You are a valued partner, and we appreciate the business that you place with us. We look forward to sharing with you the exciting updates we have planned for 2016 to help you grow your business. Look for future launch meeting information to be sent over the next several weeks. If you have any questions, please contact your New Business Manager or Broker Support.
Thank you,
Cigna Individual and Family Plans

Are you a broker in California who sells Cigna Individual and Family Plans?  Please feel free to comment below and share your thoughts!